Previous Entry | Next Entry

cali: (Jack = hot (jr_moon))
= So the season finale of SGA has been watched. Honestly? I'm pretty disappointed with the second season in general. There were some great episodes and a lot of wonderful and fun moments but I feel like the writers were taking a huge break from logic when they wrote the season's arc. I mean are we honestly supposed to believe that all of these highly educated, supposedly experienced people are actually this stupid? Because the command decision making has been pretty shitty overall from the decision to make a retrovirus that turns a wraith into a human being to the decision to believe that they could actually be allies with them without getting stabbed in the back.

With the benefit of having watched SG-1 now, I have to say I am intrigued with some of the questionable decisions the Atlantis team has been making. We know from season one of SGA that the Ancients aren't exactly the do-gooders we might expect (what with the biological warfare experimentation) but more interesting to me is the fact that in SG-1 the Asgard, friends of earth and highly evolved beings, are also not infallibly good. The fact is, they'd been making treaties with the Goa'uld System Lords for years. They knew they couldn't stop the Goa'uld cold so they decided to do what they could, protect those planets they could and let the Goa'uld continue enslaving and tormenting the human populations on the worlds they couldn't protect. Honestly, the possible parallels between the Asgard's willingness to work with the Goa'uld and the Atlantean's grudging willingness to strike their deal with the wraith interests me. I'm not sure the show's writers will ever be able to justify a lot of the Atlantis team's stupid decisions over the past season but I think they could have had a pretty good shot at making me feel a little better about them if they drew the right parallels.

= Bush's State of the Union address didn't fail to piss me off again this year. The man clearly doesn't live in the same world as the rest of the country what with the healthcare's doing great! the economy's doing great! american workers can't be stopped! let's promote science and math education without making education any more affordable! abstinence only education is working great! bullshit. Also? The smirking really, really annoys me. The upside to all of this was that Stephen Colbert and John Stewart got to mock the shit out of Bush in funny and inventive ways. John Stewart is my hero. He really, really is.

= Also? Stargate (the movie) was an answer on Jeopardy tonight and I swear to god I'm getting better are that game every time I watch. It's really quite gratifying.

= My class on Reality and the New Physics seems like it's going to be a pretty awesome class. We're reading a bunch of interesting sounding books and my Professor for it is an ex-research physicist out of Stanford's Linear Accelerator Center. The vote is still out on my Mexican-US Politics class. I'm afraid I don't know much of anything about Mexican history and I don't speak a word of Spanish so I'm worried I'll be out of my depth for that class. I'm still on track to graduate in May though so that's pretty damned exciting *g*

Comments

[identity profile] anitac588.livejournal.com wrote:
Feb. 2nd, 2006 10:00 am (UTC)
I mean are we honestly supposed to believe that all of these highly educated, supposedly experienced people are actually this stupid?
Word, word and word again to raising this question. It pisses me off to no end that someone keeps telling me we're smart, brilliant, the most intelligent in the galaxy, genious again and again, yet it does not fail to do the most naive, stupid, downright dumb decision again and again and yet again. I mean, Genii may be 60 yrs behind the nuclear research with woefully inadequate shielding, yet they outwit both SGA team and Wraith for that matter on every occasion. Not so smart, our SGA, eh?

Again the policy tell us, not show us - just like it is with Lex on SV. He is alleged genious, but the number of seasons he needed to understand htat he's security sucks begs to differ that fact.
[identity profile] theantimodel.livejournal.com wrote:
Feb. 4th, 2006 01:33 am (UTC)
Oh yes especially to the Lex correlation. Nothing pissed me off more about the Lex storyline than the bad badness of all of the attempts to hit us over the head with blunt objects while yelling look he's really smart! look he's super evil!
[identity profile] fuskeez.livejournal.com wrote:
Feb. 2nd, 2006 03:56 pm (UTC)
I think it's disappointing mostly because the potential for great storytelling is so high, as you said, when drawing the right parallels. And wouldn't you think, with so many of the same writers. I just feel like they've gotten sloppy at times.

And don't get me started on their stupidity. Granted, the folks on SG1 have been a little dumb over the years as well so I'm kindof used to it, but it's still frustrating.
[identity profile] theantimodel.livejournal.com wrote:
Feb. 4th, 2006 01:35 am (UTC)
Exactly, it's more frustrating than anything else for me. I really like SGA and I love the potential of it all, but I feel like the writers gave up a little or something. It kind of reminded me of that SG-1 episode with the Gadmeer where RDA was pissed because he didn't think O'Neill would act the way he was written in that episode but the writers didn't have time to change it and the whole cast just had to grit their teeth and so it anyways. I wonder sometimes if any of the SGA actors feel the same way with some of their storylines.
[identity profile] fuskeez.livejournal.com wrote:
Feb. 4th, 2006 01:40 am (UTC)
Ya know, I *just* watched the Scorched Earth commentary a couple of nights ago, so luckily I knew your reference. That was such an interesting situation they had in that case. But I'll say, RDA made it so much more complex *because* of that discomfort.

You're right though, it's possible that it could be happening on SGA. However maybe because these are much newer characters to these actors, they don't have as strong a foothold on how they would or wouldn't react as much as RDA had at that time. It'll be interesting to see this play out in coming seasons.