Previous Entry | Next Entry

cali: (kill (spicedrum))
A lot of people have been promoting voter registration lately, and I've sort of wanted to speak up about it for a while. A lot of people are putting emphasis on the upcoming election, talking about how crucial it is and how necessary it is that people register and vote and make their voices heard. I suppose I have a slightly different veiwpoint here but the fact that I haven't said anything has been bothering me. So. Here goes.

Voting isn't the answer.

And I'm not saying this because I think Kerry isn't the answer. I am saying it because I think the system is too fucked for an election or a change of face to make better. The United States is not even a direct democracy. Everyone keeps talking about the power of the vote when the reality is that individual votes don't count. The electoral college elects the president, not us. Our votes? They're a lot more like an opinion poll than anything else. We vote for our state electors who, in turn, cast votes for the president and vice president. It is traditional for the electors to follow the will of the people, but it isn't required by law that they do so. The entire system was designed by the founding fathers as a safeguard against the people's inability to make the right decision. It was designed specifically to remove democratic power from the hands of the people and put it into the hands of smarter, educated men who could be counted on to make the right decision.

So what? One might say. The electoral college has always bowed to convention and voted with the people in the past. But honestly? Without any check to their power I think it's a pretty dangerous precedent to still have the electoral college alive and kicking today.

I also think the party system and the importance of money on elections is dangerous. John Kerry has proven himself just as willing as Bush when it comes to allowing himself to be bought by corporations. He's spoken out against soft money, but apparently had no problems taking it before the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act passed. All of you should check out Open Secrets in particular their Presidential Election data to see the exact state of both Bush and Kerry's campaign finances. You should also read this article by Bill Mesler about the corporate financing of this election.

What this stuff boils down to, for me, is that Kerry is absolutely no better than Bush when it comes down to the things that count. Neither man is willing to make any significant changes to the status quo. And for some of you guys that might be okay, but for me it's not. Neither one will stand up to their corporate backers and admit that capitalism is destroying the planet and the lives of every poverty stricken person on it. Neither will recognize that change starts at home when it comes to nuclear disarmament and proliferation. Neither is going to address the serious problem of the prison-industrial complex, and neither Bush nor Kerry is willing to put people before profits when it comes to civil rights over property rights. And since I don't have a couple hundred thousand dollars to give either of those guys, my opinions won't ever be heard.

I think that if Kerry wins this election a lot of "liberals" are going to breath a sigh of relief that a democrat is back in office and take a few steps back from paying attention to politics for the next four years. This attitude is a problem. I've done my part to serve my country, now I can step back and let the people I voted for do their jobs.

Casting a vote takes 15 minutes. But what about the next 3 years 364 days and 23 hours?

Tags:

Comments

[identity profile] konishi-zen.livejournal.com wrote:
Sep. 28th, 2004 11:11 pm (UTC)
I have read your views on it and to some point, it's true that in America, you guys are pretty much fucked six ways till Sunday.

But...have you also considered that just sitting there bitching about what crooks the people running are isn't exactly a better option?

Yeah, the US voting system (Which pretty much is as anachronistic as you can get with a voting system) blows goats and it's all run by rich coporations and the like.

But...change takes time and the more people stop being so apathetic about their own freaking country, the more the change can be processed at a much faster rate.

I'm not saying your point isn't valid, but Apathy isn't the right answer. Also, if you feel so strongly about the buggers running your nation, maybe you can start up a movement rather than bitching.

I don't believe in the democratic voting system either, but I vote every single time I get. I grew up in a military dictatorship, where voting didn't count for jack-all. I don't see it as my patriotic duty or such nonsense. I see it as a small action towards some change and...four years of bitching rights.

Plus, if the US is just as horrible, come up to Canada or go to Australia. They actually care about the voting process.
[identity profile] theantimodel.livejournal.com wrote:
Sep. 28th, 2004 11:19 pm (UTC)
Dude, if I was feeling apathetic I'd never have written this post. My point is that voting isn't the answer, but I never said that people should just sit back and do nothing. What I did say was that it's dangerous to think that casting a vote is the only thing people can do to make a difference. I think voting is probably the last thing a person should do if they're trying to enact change. Voting is a passive action, it's the least involved a person can be in politics while still feeling like they're making a difference.

Personally, (and I hand't brought this up because this post isn't about how much of an activist I am) I do take action, I am involved with numerous causes and groups working to enact changes that i think need to happen. I've attended virtually every political rally in my location in the past three years. So I am involved and I am trying to make a difference. I'm just not going to vote for the lesser of two evils in a campaign where I think the entire system is wrong.
[identity profile] konishi-zen.livejournal.com wrote:
Sep. 28th, 2004 11:32 pm (UTC)
I see what you mean about it being a passive action, but to a lot of people, that is the only type of agency they do have to make some sort of difference where they are living.

Also, about activism. It's great, no denying it. But Change has to start somewhere, and maybe starting it in the system (ie voting) would let the other elements in.